Two recent news stories about the death penalty have me thinking about my opinions on society’s ultimate penalty. Last week in Tennessee, Christa Pike was given two lethal injections in the death chamber, and survived them both. She awoke earlier this week in a hospital and while she is still reported to have some brain issues, was well enough to ask where she was. Weirdly, authorities went from trying to kill her, to trying to save her life. It’s a bizarre story and where it goes from here is anybody’s guess.
We were also told this week that Army Major Dr. Nidal Hasan, who was convicted in a military tribunal in 2013 of murdering 13 fellow soldiers in 2009, will be executed by firing squad in December. Secretary of Defense (or War) Hegseth has said the execution will be live-streamed.
These cases are not alike in that Hasan was court-martialed in a military tribunal under the Uniform Code of Military Justice. The process is much different than civilian jurisprudence.
I grew up during the timeframe when many/most states had the death penalty and I remember the Supreme Court halting executions in 1972 because they were being applied in a manner that violated the Eighth Amendment against cruel and unusual punishment. They were allowed back in use under new laws beginning in 1976.
As a young police officer witnessing violent crime, I strongly supported the death penalty. As I matured, my views have changed. I saw few murder cases (either personally or in the news,) where I thought the death penalty would have been a deterrent to what the murderer did. I’ve come to put murderers in three (very) general buckets; murders of passion, murders committed in the commission of another crime, and psychopaths. None of these people are great at gauging (or caring) about the consequences of their acts in real time.
Nor did I believe the time between a conviction for murder, and a death sentence being carried out, (almost 25 years today,) provided the measure of justice that the families of victims thought it would. Even after an execution, I’m not sure the survivors feel the justice they thought they would, not including the 25 wasted years of thinking it would bring finality.
It’s impossible to determine the exact number of murder convictions in the U.S. last year but roughly 70% of almost 15,000 murders were solved, so approximately 9,800 people were charged with murder. Nationally, 70% of murderers are convicted, so approximately 6,800 murder convictions occurred. Also last year, there were 47 total executions, so about half a percent of convicted murderers get the death penalty every year. Clearly, the death penalty is not applied evenly, or in a timely manner.
I did some research in a graduate criminology class where I learned the old canard that executing criminals saved the taxpayers from years of housing them was demonstrably false. Because not only do we house them for those 25 intervening years, we pay a ton of money toward their mandatory death penalty appeals.
In 2001, as an FBI field supervisor I oversaw a small task force in Indiana that monitored threats to the upcoming execution of Oklahoma City bomber Timothy McVeigh. There were small militia movements across the country who threatened to travel to the federal penitentiary and break him out before the execution, among other threats. McVeigh was in contact with several of these actors. We didn’t think any of the plots were viable, but they needed to be investigated.
In June of that year I was at McVeigh’s execution, though not inside the execution chamber. It was surreal.
Every television network had erected news booths overlooking the federal prison. The morning shows were all live from Terre Haute. Vendors sold tee shirts and cotton candy on the grounds surrounding the prison. A woman drove four hours in a convertible wearing a wedding dress and brought a cake; she tried to enter the prison because (she claimed) she had been in touch with McVeigh and he wanted to marry her before he died. One of the officials in charge of the execution showed up in a new, wide-pinstriped suit and a fedora.
If anybody deserved to die for his crimes, it was McVeigh. But the whole atmosphere looked more like a circus than jurisprudence.
Shortly after I retired from the FBI, my local district attorney convened a panel to review convictions she thought were problematic and I was asked to be on that panel. The first case we reviewed involved two men who’d been convicted of the murder of a woman in 1976 and who were initially sentenced to death, which was later reduced to life in prison.
The case was problematic and rested on a single witnesses’ testimony, despite more than 25 other witnesses who claimed they were down the street at a party. There was no other evidence. Several years after they went to prison, another man confessed. Despite that, their appeals were continually turned down on technicalities. After an extensive re-investigation of the facts, the panel voted unanimously they should be released after 42 years in prison. The Court agreed.
So, I’m conflicted. It is hard for me to argue the Timothy McVeigh’s and Nidal Hasan’s don’t deserve the ultimate penalty for their crimes - they do. But for many other death penalty cases, I struggle with the concepts of who gets it, when, and most of all, getting it wrong. And then it’s not fixable.
Let me know in the comments below what you think about the death penalty.
WHAT I’M WORKING ON
My Air America - CIA Thriller, GRAY GHOST has been out for a little more that a month and has done very well. I didn’t start out certain I wanted it to be a series, but I enjoyed writing the Chase Black character, as well as the concept of historical fiction. So book two in the series is underway; stay tuned for details, cover reveal, pre-orders, etc. Order GRAY GHOST here .
I released a short story, WEST OF LAGUNA several weeks ago exclusively in eBook. It was a fun story that I had in a virtual desk drawer and I thought, “What the heck.” I like the concept, and am going to do more short stories. Order WEST OF LAGUNA here.
In fact, stay tuned for the release very soon of a novella, again in eBook only, featuring Diplomatic Security Special agent Vance Kane. I’m thinking of releasing it here, free to subscribers in several short serials, before it comes out anywhere else. When it does come out elsewhere, It will disappear from my Substack column. Tell me your thoughts on that idea.
Finally, I continue to work on notes and the outline for a (first) non-fiction book on the January 5th pipe bomb case. That is a long term project because there are criminal and civil cases yet to be resolved.
Until next time,
F.X.



Well said. I am not an anti- death penalty advocate, although as I described I've evolved to oppose it. It's biblical, and some are clearly deserving of the ultimate penalty. My biggest obstacle to supporting it is getting it wrong. Executing an innocent person. It has certainly happened in our country and throughout history.
Let me recommend this:
https://www.thefp.com/p/i-support-the-death-penalty-dont-public-justice-livestream?r=3bo55&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web